The experience that my son and I had was exceptional.

Quite old fashioned decor. Hotel huge so very busy.

Great golfing weekend away, amazing value for money. Entertainment in the bar area was also fantastic, will be back 😄

We had a fabulous time at Celtic Manor, the facilities are fantastic. Spa facilities were second to none and so relaxing including all the treatments i had while we were there. Would certainly return in the future.

Very expensive and we ate in the Rib Smokehouse and Grill restaurant and this was very pricey for 4 of us. Service was very slow at the merlin bar as well and people kept jumping in to be served! We went as couples and ended up having to have single beds again after we asked for a double bed and nothing was done. All in all a below average stay for a supposed luxury resort.

Very large complex- evening buffet in Olive Tree average - breakfast better but wouldn't want to eat there when busy- cafe like experience.

We had a lovely golf break very helpful staff especially a lovely lady called Lin who was serving us with tea and coffee at breakfast, the hotel room was comfortable with wide reaching views over the golf course. The courses were in great condition, although the price of the golf carts were very expensive at £38 a day.

You get a very small taste of what it must be like being a tour pro when you play The Twenty Ten course. Great hosts at the Celtic Manor. Couldn't find fault anywhere.

My Caddy Tip - "Always club up as the wind is deceiving."

Handicap - 18

I would go back without hesitation, good hotel even if you are not golfing. You are very well looked after, buggies loaded up and waiting for you. The course is amazing with fabulous views and spectacular holes, especially the ones over the gorges (take plenty of balls). The only downside is that if you go in winter not all the restaurants are open.

My Caddy Tip - "Take care on the steep slopes."

Stableford Score - 35 points

Handicap - 18

9th hole was my favourite.

Handicap - 28

Amazing stay which was made by the staff. They could not do enough for you.

Stableford Score - 30 points

Handicap - 20

Hotel was very good, with the best breakfast you could wish for. Courses were wet but still played well. The whole 2010 experience is very special and I'd recommend it to anyone who loves their golf.

My Caddy Tip - "Check the distance, pick your club, then take one longer."

Stableford Score - 33 points

Handicap - 10

Played 2 courses. There is a great curry restaurant down the road from the hotel. Trying to get a foursome for next year.

My Caddy Tip - "Keep your head still and don't try to hit the ball too hard."

Stableford Score - 28 or less points

Handicap - 18

Throughout the whole course I was left with a long second shot and there was always an obstacle of either a bunker or water hazard to overcome. However, a great place nonetheless.

Stableford Score - 31 points

Handicap - 18

It was great playing the 2010 (Ryder Cup) course. Great course; great food (and cocktails) on the night we stayed; great advice from the staff ("don't bother with a buggy on the 2010 course as only the last few holes involve climbs") - in other words just great!

My Caddy Tip - "Use a distance measuring device, some of the shots are further than they look."

Stableford Score - 30 points

Handicap - 11

Lovely hotel, but we were let down by the weather, so slightly disappointed.

Handicap - 28

All very enjoyable and I will be going back again and again.

My Caddy Tip - "Enjoy your golf."

Stableford Score - 36 points

Handicap - 12

Enjoy it.

Stableford Score - 31 points

Handicap - 5

Could not stay on site and had to go to the hotel outside the complex, double booked. The courses were flooded, should have been closed. Unfortunately could not finish the golf trip.

My Caddy Tip - "Keep it on the fairway."

Stableford Score - 28 or less points

Handicap - 6

Preferred the Montgomerie course. It was great fun to play but I would have a buggy next time as there are some long walks between holes. Manor house was very nice but the food was not good and the drinks very expensive.

My Caddy Tip - "If you are on the wrong side of the hole on the Montgomerie course 3 putts can be a good result."

Stableford Score - 34 points

Handicap - 15

Love the whole 2010 experience.

Stableford Score - 34 points

Handicap - 6

Imagine the crowds are there during every shot. It's fantastic. Birdie the eighteenth to win like McDowell. Relax in one of the most stunning hotels in Wales. Great food great beer great prices.

My Caddy Tip - "Check out Gareth Edwards playing 2010 on YouTube."

Stableford Score - 31 points

Handicap - 19

Hotel was spot on. The Montgomerie Course had some great views, particularly the par 4 hole that plays directly down hill.

Handicap - 14

The 2010 experience is a must, It's like playing a different resort. The Manor House is fine for an overnight stay but the 5 star hotel is the one.

My Caddy Tip - "Aim for the bunkers as unless you hit long you won't reach them, but you will be pointed in the right direction."

Stableford Score - 33 points

Handicap - 21

Stay at the hotel.

Stableford Score - 37 points

Handicap - 21

Had a great two day break. Loved the hotel- in particular, the lovely spa and pool and the delicious breakfast in the morning. Played the Montgomerie and Roman Road on two glorious February days. I particularly liked the Montgomerie, it had beautiful views, was well kept and the par 5 hole 3 was a delight.

My Caddy Tip - "Drive straight."

Stableford Score - 32 points

Handicap - 21

Everything was good.

Handicap - 18

Fantastic hotel, spa and golf course. What more can you need.

Handicap - 16

A well run resort with a fabulous range of three very different courses, combined with an excellent hotel, good food and very professional staff. What more could anyone want? Even the weather was kind to us.

My Caddy Tip - "Pay attention to distance and direction of second shots. There are some hidden changes of direction and slopes on the fairways as well as challenging bunkers on all three courses."

Stableford Score - 39 or more points

Handicap - 13

Hotel was fabulous.

My Caddy Tip - "Read the greens, choose a 3 wood or driver"

Stableford Score - 35 points

Handicap - 16

First time playing the 2010 course and the raised greens with 'run-offs' got me a few times! Will play again and score better hopefully. 5* service all around. Had evening meal at clubhouse- fantastic food. We will be back!

My Caddy Tip - "On your approach shot, treat the breaks on the raised greens with the greatest respect."

Stableford Score - 31 points

Handicap - 25

All holes have their own characteristics, so no real complaints about the course.

My Caddy Tip - "Always hit the the center of the greens and take the two putts."

Stableford Score - 37 points

Handicap - 15

The twenty ten course for me. Every hole is a challenge, you have to be as straight as possible and try to keep it on the fairway. Hotel was excellent and we were we'll looked after. The food was very nice. 24 of us went and no one complained and we have some moaners in our group.

My Caddy Tip - "Hit more club than you think."

Stableford Score - 32 points

Handicap - 9

Grand entrance with an excellent meet and greet team.

Handicap - 12

Great courses, great holes

My Caddy Tip - "Practice your driving as you need to be straight on most holes."

Stableford Score - 32 points

Handicap - 28

My favourite hole would be the 3rd, the views are outstanding. Hotel and food, as you can imagine were stunning.

Stableford Score - 33 points

Handicap - 11

Was woken at 6am by loud banging. My room was next to maintenance. Food staff were awful at breakfast and at the spike bar. Did complain to reception on leaving, they didn't want to be there. A shame because the golf staff and courses were excellent.

My Caddy Tip - "Bring a yardage measurer and camera for the views."

Stableford Score - 32 points

Handicap - 15

Everything was superb, especially the way all the staff look after you. A real experience. Have been back twice since.

Stableford Score - 35 points

Handicap - 10

Hotel great, the Monty course was to hilly.

Stableford Score - 28 or less points

Handicap - 20

Golf was great but several issues with the 5* hotel.

My Caddy Tip - "Practice putting before going on course."

Stableford Score - 37 points

Handicap - 25

Top place to play and stay. Fantastic courses.

My Caddy Tip - "Lay up on 18 it's further than you think."

Stableford Score - 33 points

Handicap - 9

Played the Montgomerie and the 2010 Course, the latter something special. Hotel was good, breakfast and dinner very nice. Staff at hotel and at Golf venues were excellent.

Stableford Score - 28 or less points

Handicap - 20

Stableford Score - 34 points

Handicap - 12

Played all three courses, support from all the staff was very good, and it was very good value.

Handicap - 15

All of the courses were very enjoyable.

My Caddy Tip - "Keep on the fairway."

Stableford Score - 28 or less points

Handicap - 7

Course was lovely, 2010 course was outstanding.

My Caddy Tip - "Make sure you get it on the hole."

Stableford Score - 28 or less points

Handicap - 9

Courses wonderful but extremely wet and we were surprised they were open. Greens were fantastic and very fast. Fantastic reception at the 2010 clubhouse. Celtic Manor hotel was very good but restaurants were very quiet which spoiled the atmosphere.

My Caddy Tip - "Take more club for each shot."

Stableford Score - 28 or less points

Handicap - 11

Great courses, great holes.

My Caddy Tip - "Practice your driving, you need to be straight on most holes."

Stableford Score - 32 points

Handicap - 28

1st hole on 2010 was very nerve racking but brilliant at the same time, pictures by a professional photographer on the 1st tee while taking your shot was awesome. My advise for anyone who wants to play there is to get a course planner out of the pro shop, as this will save you shots. Hotel was second to none, fantastic 5*. Spa was also amazing, food was great, beer was pricey in the main bar but there is a sports bar on the complex which was a great little find that also does food.

My Caddy Tip - "Attack the greens as they stick when they hit."

Stableford Score - 38 points

Handicap - 19

Hotel was great. Food options were also great. 2010 course is a must. Superb 18 holes.

My Caddy Tip - "Just enjoy it."

Stableford Score - 32 points

Handicap - 24

I had a great break with 3 friends. Golf, hotel and food was excellent.

My Caddy Tip - "Keep it on the fairway."

Stableford Score - 33 points

Handicap - 9

Service was on point.

Handicap - 16

Hotel fantastic. I recommend hiring a buggy as the courses are long with big gaps to next tees.

My Caddy Tip - "Play to your strengths."

Stableford Score - 31 points

Handicap - 17

Playing the 17th par 3 on the 2010 course was a great experience as was remembering G Mac closing out the winning score of the 2010 Ryder Cup. Still feel the excitement of it today and every time we return to the Celtic Manor. Must try the fish and chips in the bar area after a round.

My Caddy Tip - "On 18th on the 2010 ensure you aim left of the green and get it there."

Stableford Score - 33 points

Handicap - 14

Didn't really have any favourite holes. I know it was early in the year (mid march), but the course was quite waterlogged. Even though the month before was quite dry, I don't feel a urge to re-visit. The hotel was fine, all staff were friendly and very helpful. My only tip is "If you think a 6 iron is needed, use a 5".

My Caddy Tip - "Use a higher iron, distance is deceptive"

Handicap - 34

Played Montgomerie and Roman Road courses with this year being our 4th consecutive year and the quality of the courses was better than ever. Have played the 2010 course twice already and whilst more expensive it is worth trying at least once for a great experience on a very tough course. The 2 we played are still a real test of skill, especially the greens which were lightening quick and if you're in the rough it would usually mean a lost ball, even when quite close to the fairways. The views on the course are fantastic and at this time of year it was fairly quiet so plenty of time to enjoy the round and not feel rushed by following groups. 

The resort hotel is excellent, although drinks and food expensive - but it is a 5 star hotel. If open, try the cellar bar where they have happy hour sometimes and a decent value menu - sports screens all around, a pool table and darts board. Unfortunately when we went the french rugby team had secured the venue and other parts of the hotel for their own private use. This was not advised to us at the time of booking and was a great disappointment. The hotel staff were clearly embarrassed and apologised profusely, and it was obvious they were fed up with having to apologise over and over again to every visitor to this bar and restaurant.

My Caddy Tip - "Very fast greens."

Stableford Score - 28 or less points

Handicap - 20

Resort hotel excellent. Would prefer to play 2010 course next time however. The Roman Road course did not flow, but enjoyed the Montgomerie!

My Caddy Tip - "Play percentage shots"

Stableford Score - 29 points

Handicap - 18

I played the 2010 and the rough was like a hay field, not fun.

My Caddy Tip - "Buy a course guide."

Stableford Score - 33 points

Handicap - 5

Superb facilities with 2 brilliant courses. Get a buggy for the Montgomery course as it is extremely hilly. You are made to feel special by all the hotel and golf staff. Extremely good value for what you get, already thinking about returning. Food was superb too.

My Caddy Tip - "Play to your ability, don't bite off more then you can chew as these courses can spit you out."

Stableford Score - 32 points

Handicap - 11

Golf, rooms, food all excellent. Only downside was that buggies have to stay on the paths. Played Roman Road and four holes of the Montgomerie and then torrential rain got to us.

Handicap - 33

2010 is a fantastic golf course. We were a group of mainly single figure handicaps and were allowed to go off back tees. Awesome! Accommodation was great and the welcome and service in the smaller Manor House was far better than the hotel we stayed in on a previous trip. Each time we have travelled a mile down the road to eat at The Bell at Caerleon- excellent little pub restaurant. Call in advance to book and the hospitality is ace.

My Caddy Tip - "Walk to the practice ground at 2010 and soak up the atmosphere as you walk down to the 1st tee."

Stableford Score - 33 points

Handicap - 1

Absolutely chucked it down and we had force 8 gale! Played 6 holes on 2010 and were then able to take a rain check and get an adverse weather voucher so we could go back. Went back a year later and got rained off again. Course was in pretty good condition given the amount of rain. "Rivers" through the greens though on Monty course. Another voucher issued, although they didn't cover the full cost and you still have the cost of a buggy that isn't refunded. Good to receive them though. Hotel good.

Stableford Score - 31 points

Handicap - 13

This was a truly first class occasion, for all of our group. The welcome on the 2010 and the day was excellent but it was a true test and no-one came close to their handicap.

My Caddy Tip - "Hit straight not long."

Stableford Score - 28 or less points

Handicap - 18

We enjoyed the hotel and its facilities but playing all three courses on three consecutive days in winter conditions was not a good idea for people of our age.

Handicap - 14

2010 course too tough for 18 handicap and over, Montgomerie ok. Roman Road was also tough but all the courses were enjoyable.

My Caddy Tip - "Play within your limitations."

Stableford Score - 29 points

Handicap - 17

The whole resort is set up to make the average golfer feel special. The Montgomerie course was my favourite, even over the 2010, but all 3 courses are memorable. The hotel and leisure facilities are superb and the food just topped it off. If you are a club golfer looking for the ultimate golfing experience, travel to Celtic Manor, you won't be disappointed.

My Caddy Tip - "Think your way around."

Stableford Score - 32 points

Handicap - 16

2010 is incredible, tough but fair. Both other courses are very good. Nice to have a few beers in the Lodge Cellar Bar, although they need to sort Sky Sport out. Meal in main clubhouse was really good. Breakfast at Lodge had really poor service and quality, but this in no way spoilt the weekend. It's a 'must visit' for all golfers.

Stableford Score - 29 points

Handicap - 7

Great short break playing golf. Would recommend it to anyone's who likes a challenge. Hotel lovely. Food very expensive, but nice.

Stableford Score - 32 points

Handicap - 16

It was an absolutely great place to play golf. Staff are great and the courses are great too. Lovely food and an all round great atmosphere.

My Caddy Tip - "Just get the ball round."

Stableford Score - 39 or more points

Handicap - 24

Played the Roman Rd and the Montgomery which I enjoyed, with the exception of members bombarding us with golf balls whilst on the green. Nothing was done to resolve the problem. The service in the hotel was far short of the 5 star supposed rating- I wrote a detailed complaint about the hotel which included the golfing incident and the overcharging at final billing, none of which were resolved by Celtic Manor. I would recommend anyone to go and play the courses as they and the green keeping staff were excellent and many of the peripheral staff also. Do not however, be fooled by the Hotel 5 star rating as it fell exceedingly short of that rating. It would have been wonderful if Celtic Manor had offered some reparation for the substandard service experienced during my stay that unfortunately destroyed what would have been a very enjoyable golfing break had it not been for the aforementioned unfortunate issues.

My Caddy Tip - "Carefully plan your approaches to greens."

Stableford Score - 38 points

Handicap - 14

The food at the hotel was excellent, as was the service.

My Caddy Tip - "Take extra care on reading putts. The greens are true, so if you miss it's a miss read."

Stableford Score - 33 points

Handicap - 22

The hotel was fantastic, hospitality was second to none, the only complaint that my party had was the drinks were a bit expensive. Looking forward to venue next year.

Stableford Score - 39 or more points

Handicap - 14

Stableford Score - 30 points

Handicap - 14

Tired accommodation. Queues to get out over an hour long as very slow play. Go to the Belfry instead.

Stableford Score - 30 points

Handicap - 30

Played both 2010 and Montgomerie courses. Great feeling just knowing the Ryder Cup was played on the 2010 course and you're walking in the footsteps of the professionals. Little touches made the day special, i.e. your name on the locker in the changing room on the 2010 course. Everything about the hotel was excellent, well maintained, big rooms, clean and tidy, etc.

My Caddy Tip - "Hire a buggy for the Montgomerie Course."

Stableford Score - 28 or less points

Handicap - 14

Course and hotel like it says- 5 star. Very friendly staff.

Stableford Score - 36 points

Handicap - 12

Preferred the Montgomerie course.

My Caddy Tip - "Practice putting for sure."

Stableford Score - 34 points

Handicap - 12

My tip- if you play the Montgomerie, get a buggy unless you are really fit.

My Caddy Tip - "Check yardages as it plays longer than it looks."

Stableford Score - 37 points

Handicap - 6

Enjoyed playing the 2010 but its a long course and it makes you think where to aim and lay up to ensure you hit the greens. The rough can be punishing when it's wet so don't miss the fairways. Everything from the practice range, staff and accommodation was perfect. We also sampled the evening buffet meal option which was exceptional in terms of value, quality and quantity. This venue should be on everyone's to do list.

My Caddy Tip - "Greens are true and fair."

Stableford Score - 34 points

Handicap - 13

The 3rd hole on the Monty is good. Get a buggy as it is very hilly. Lovely hotel. Tough to beat for value.

My Caddy Tip - "Get a buggy."

Stableford Score - 37 points

Handicap - 8

Hotel is great. All the courses are good, even the less used Roman Road.

My Caddy Tip - "Try to keep the ball in play."

Stableford Score - 28 or less points

Handicap - 14

Let every one enjoy there own experience.

Stableford Score - 35 points

Handicap - 11

Third hole on the Montgomery is brilliant. Celtic Manor is a great venue not only or the golf but also the ambiance of the place- the rooms are clean and tidy, the spa and sauna are well looked after, the food in the restaurant is at a high standard and I just love the breakfast. I would recommend this venue to my friends and family.

My Caddy Tip - "Very tight courses and difficult enjoy and drive it straight."

Stableford Score - 29 points

Handicap - 24

Hole 3,16 and 18 were all very good.

Stableford Score - 31 points

Handicap - 29

The grandness of the hotel and surroundings make this a remarkable experience. Go on, treat yourself. You won't regret it.

My Caddy Tip - "Use your shots wisely and go for position on greens. Get the wrong side and you're in trouble."

Stableford Score - 34 points

Handicap - 8

The Montgomery was awesome and obviously the 2010 was also great. Roman Road also very good. The Lodge was fantastic.

Stableford Score - 32 points

Handicap - 18

Favourite hole is ninth.

My Caddy Tip - "Montgomerie course gets heavy in the winter"

Stableford Score - 34 points

Handicap - 12

Loved the par 5's.

My Caddy Tip - "Keep it straight."

Stableford Score - 33 points

Handicap - 8

The hotel and food were great. The registration and lack of people to handle the baggage was diabolical. Luggage was left in the foyer unattended while reception staff tried to help.

Stableford Score - 38 points

Handicap - 26

Much prefer the Roman Road course. 2010 is somewhat too difficult for mid to high handicapper, just a long slog. Also, much prefer the Manor Hotel, which is much more homely and comfortable. Rafters Restaurant is a must, particularly for dinner.

My Caddy Tip - "Don't get too ambitious off the tee."

Stableford Score - 30 points

Handicap - 15

Everything was brilliant.

My Caddy Tip - "Know what you hit yardage wise."

Stableford Score - 30 points

Handicap - 9

Staff very helpful both in golf club and resort hotel. Appreciated adverse weather vouchers to make a return visit having been snowed off.

Stableford Score - 28 or less points

Handicap - 24

Excellent courses and hotel. Staff brilliant.

Handicap - 20

Superb courses, lovely surroundings, excellent personnel.

My Caddy Tip - "Don't be shy to take 1 more club."

Stableford Score - 33 points

Handicap - 16

My Caddy Tip - "Stay in the buggy- huge walk."

Stableford Score - 34 points

Handicap - 10

Montgomerie course was unplayable and marshals admitted this. Despite only being a 3 ball we were behind a junior 4 ball so the round took over 5 hours and wasn't marshaled at all. We werent allowed to upgrade to an empty 2010 course either. Roman road was a very basic course but still a challenge. However, the hotel and the food were fantastic as was the sports bar and happy hour. Buggies ripped leather and tired looking, and was surprised it was still classed as 5 star.

My Caddy Tip - "Play the 2010."

Stableford Score - 33 points

Handicap - 13

Superb hotel and facilities, everything catered for. Get a buggy if you play the monty.

Handicap - 10

Really enjoyed our stay at Celtic Manor. Reminded me of a Vegas hotel it was so big! Excellent facilities and a great couple of days despite the terrible weather. It did play ball when playing the 2010 course though, glorious sunshine! Definitely would recommend a buggy for 2010, large distances between green and tee.

My Caddy Tip - "Get the buggy, and use the practice facilities at 2010 course."

Handicap - 28

Hotel was fantastic (as per other members in the party). The hosts were brilliant- looked after our needs and also provided separate room for the presentations etc. Sadly I had to leave early as my father was taken ill.

Handicap - 24

The Ryder Cup course at the time played is overpriced and over-rated, living very much on its history. I'd never go there again at this time of year, if ever. There is just too much foot traffic when it's damp, I can't remember bumpier greens at any other championship course.

My Caddy Tip - "Expect to miss a load of putts, anything you hole is a bonus."

Stableford Score - 32 points

Handicap - 5

Excellent hotel and courses in excellent condition providing a real test.

My Caddy Tip - "Keep the ball in the fairway."

Stableford Score - 30 points

Handicap - 19

Wet, wet and wet. Puddles on greens. Should have been closed in all honesty.

My Caddy Tip - "Take an umbrella."

Stableford Score - 30 points

Handicap - 18

I've been here a few times with large groups, couples and corporates, each time I visit The Celtic Manor I'm always impressed by the service and quality of product. The Roman Road and Montgomerie are decent courses in their own right and well worth a round, especially if you have a mix of handicaps in your group. Off the back tees they are a real challenge and you have to play well to get 36 points. The Twenty Ten experience is as they bill it, an experience. You are made to feel very special as you make your way into the grand clubhouse and get yourself ready to take on the course. The lockers have the Ryder Cup players from 2010 on them so you can have the likes of Rory, Tiger etc as past users of it. The course itself is a real championship layout with a mix of length and strategy needed to get your way round it. Off the tee it is quite demanding with long tee shots needed to make headway on holes like 2, 4 and 8. The closing stretch of 15, 16, 17 and 18 are as fun a 4 holes as you'll get to finish your round. Have a go at 15 to drive it in 1, do a McDowell on 16 and hole a putt for birdie, duff a chip like Mahan on 17 and err hit in the water on 18 like me. Hotel is nice, bars are good (Merlins or the Cellar Bar at the Manor House) and there are plenty of different restaurants to suit whatever your group wants. All in all, Celtic Manor is hard to beat in terms of a UK golf break.

My Caddy Tip - "Keep it in play on all the courses, on the fairway is a lot better than being in the rough!"

Stableford Score - 36 points

Handicap - 1

Favourite hole was the 18th on the 2010 course. Three top quality courses which were a pleasure to play. I would definitely recommend to individuals or groups.

My Caddy Tip - "Use driver on 10 as is easier shot."

Stableford Score - 39 or more points

Handicap - 9

Golf courses pretty good, hotel average.

My Caddy Tip - "Grip it and rip it."

Stableford Score - 32 points

Handicap - 18

Playing on the Ryder cup 2010 course was a superb experience. The course itself is a must for anyone wishing to play on top professional courses, with the added advantage of not being overly difficult if found in decent conditions. There are a few very interesting holes that require thoughtful play, with the 18th a particular highlight. Looking forward to going back and experiencing it again next year!

My Caddy Tip - "Fairways are crucial, if you get in the thick stuff, don't get too greedy coming out."

Stableford Score - 37 points

Handicap - 16

Montgomerie was my favourite course. Prepare for the length of the 2010. Hotel was very comfortable.

My Caddy Tip - "Just go out and enjoy it, round goes quick."

Stableford Score - 31 points

Handicap - 16

The hotel could have told us that they do trips to the course, etc instead of having to drive and walk.

My Caddy Tip - "Take your time."

Stableford Score - 38 points

Handicap - 21

Have visited several times over the last few years and love everything about Celtic Manor, from the courses, hotel and facilities...as well as extremely good service and food.

My Caddy Tip - "Practice a lot before taking on the 2010."

Stableford Score - 30 points

Handicap - 12

Take a buggy as it's a long course. The hotel was first class. We loved spending time there.

Stableford Score - 30 points

Handicap - 35

Good courses spoiled by slow play and not allowing enough space for each game, hotel comfortable and good food.

Stableford Score - 28 or less points

Handicap - 19

A must for all golfers, shame its in wales or I would play again, maybe one day.

My Caddy Tip - "Try not to kill the photographer on the first!"

Stableford Score - 28 or less points

Handicap - 19

Fabulous courses, superb hotel, only spoilt by the torrential rain which meant both rounds were not finished.

My Caddy Tip - "Take one club extra."

Stableford Score - 28 or less points

Handicap - 12

Enjoyed both courses we played. You really do need a buggy. Hotel very good, but food on the expensive side.

My Caddy Tip - "Just enjoy yourself."

Stableford Score - 32 points

Handicap - 18

We had a party of 8 of us over 3 days and played the Montgomerie and Roman Road courses. Both were excellent, even in winter conditions. We had a real mix of handicaps but everyone found the courses to suit all levels. Really enjoyed both courses with some stunning views from the par 5 third hole on the Monty course. The hotel and clubhouse are superb and you really cant fault it for value for money. The stewards around the course also made you feel really welcome. Have been back on a number of occasions and it always feels special.

Stableford Score - 37 points

Handicap - 22

Hotel is brilliant. No standout holes on courses as they are all are simply amazing.

My Caddy Tip - "Play safe."

Stableford Score - 30 points

Handicap - 18

Perfect in every way. Great facilities, venue and 3 beautiful courses. Notably a place to entertain your family while you play golf. Caters for everyone.

My Caddy Tip - "Bring your waterproofs!"

Stableford Score - 38 or less points

Handicap - 13

Great course and hotel which we return to every year. The staff are always accommodating and the course's are always in great condition. I would recommend to anyone and we will be back next year.

My Caddy Tip - "Practice prior."

Stableford Score - 28 or less points

Handicap - 22

Take care on greens they are quick. Take your time and get a stroke saver for shapes and distances on holes.

My Caddy Tip - "There are a lot of holes where I found that a driver or even a 3 wood was too long."

Stableford Score - 39 or more points

Handicap - 18

Fantastic hotel. I played the 2010 and the Montgomerie courses, no holes were the same and they were all excellent.

My Caddy Tip - "Play to your yardage and go for the middle of the green, not at the pin."

Stableford Score - 35 points

Handicap - 8

My top tip is to pay the extra and play the 2010 course. There are no disappointments on any of the 3 courses. The staff went that extra mile to make our stay fantastic. Get it on your bucket list.

My Caddy Tip - "Take good notice of the indexes and don't bite off more than you can chew."

Stableford Score - 29 points

Handicap - 16

Great courses, great day.

Stableford Score - 37 points

Handicap - 8

Hotel was fine but the staff were a bit moody in the downstairs bar.

Stableford Score - 32 points

Handicap - 18

Monty and 2010 both have some superb holes. Top tip- take plenty of balls.

My Caddy Tip - "Play within yourself and take plenty of club."

Stableford Score - 35 points

Handicap - 14

Great hotel, fantastic food, Courses a bit bogey would like to play in the summer

Stableford Score - 30 points

Handicap - 10

I have been to Celtic Manor 3 times in small groups and think it is the best value for money resort. The staff go above the expected standard of service, the rooms are more than comfortable and the hotel is very restful and comfortable. All 3 courses are challenging to the average golfer but I would not recommend a buggy, more trouble than worth as you have to stick to the paths and end up walking further. The hills on the Monty are very challenging for the not so fit. Going back next week.

My Caddy Tip - "Take your wet weather gear."

Stableford Score - 28 or less points

Handicap - 20

The whole place is the real deal, just fantastic.

My Caddy Tip - "Look at the greens on approach."

Stableford Score - 31 points

Handicap - 12

Really enjoyed all three golf courses. However the service and the staff were poor. 

1. Extremely slow play (they had 250 people on the Roman Road at one time, it took over 6 hours to get round despite the continuous warnings about slow play) 

2. Lost golf towel while our clubs were in their care and they did not seem the care and only replaced it after 2 days and a long conversation with the manager. 

3. Due to the golf round taking longer than expected we missed our dinner reservation and was told we could only eat at the bar as they were serving food until 9 pm. When we got to the bar at 8:15 pm we were told that they could not serve us any food and we had to order room service. This was not acceptable. 

4. Despite booking and having been confirmed as a twin room we were given a double which had to be changed. 

5. We were told check-in was at 12 am and 2 pm and when we got there they told us we would have to wait until 5 pm. 

6. We had booked a buggy for all rounds of golf. We were told they would cost £32 when we booked these over the phone. However, we paid different prices each day. £30 the first, £34 the second and £36 the third. Inconsistent. they did not seem the care and only replaced it after 2 days and a long conversation with the manager.

Stableford Score - 34 points

Handicap - 18

This is a must for any golfer. Fairways are long off the tee so you need to clear 200 yards from the yellows. Hire a buggy as the walking between holes is excessive, but the fairways and greens are amazing. The hotel itself is stunning and the choice of food overwhelming. You must play here at least once.

Stableford Score - 32 points

Handicap - 15

The courses are a decent test and in my opinion, very fun to play. The clubhouses are classy and relaxed. The hotel is superb and the service within the hotel is fantastic.

My Caddy Tip - "Adjust clubs for elevation"

Handicap - 11

Great venue, the 2010 course is stunning.

Handicap - 13

The room was lovely but they could up the food standards. For a hotel of this caliber the buffets were not first class and I would prefer waiter service and a proper dining room. The courses were lovely but had tracks for the buggy's which then meant taking clubs over to where the ball was. This was not ideal at all. We tried trolleys but again getting from the greens back onto the tracks was really difficult.

My Caddy Tip - "Watch the slopes up to the greens on the Montgomerie."

Stableford Score - 28 or less points

Handicap - 23

Probably the worst venue I've been too.

Stableford Score - 39 or more points

Handicap - 11

I liked the Par 5 3rd hole on the Montgomerie, as well as the 18th on the 2010 but generally speaking found the holes on the 2010 with water to be the most challenging. A tip for first timers would be to have a buggy on the Montgomerie. We had buggies on the 2010 but not on the Montgomerie and it would have been better the other way around.

My Caddy Tip - "Take plenty of balls "

Stableford Score - 33 points

Handicap - 15

Hotel was great, played two courses and would like to go back to play the 2010.

My Caddy Tip - "Don't use a buggy."

Stableford Score - 37 points

Handicap - 17

Some stunning holes, can't remember which ones as there was so many. The quality of all the courses make you feel like a professional playing them.

Handicap - 13

Total wash out. Service not as good as last time. Golf and hotel were good. Food was poor for a 4 star rest/hotel. Have been to lesser high profiled places, which knock Celtic Manor into a cocked hat.

My Caddy Tip - "Don't be afraid to take one club more if necessary."

Stableford Score - 35 points

Handicap - 12

Great Hotel (the main Celtic Manor Hotel). Everything was fabulous- food, service, rooms, etc. However, our trip was spoiled by putting two non-golfers to play with my partner and myself (we play off 13 & 17). This ruined our whole day. I suggested to the pro shop that they should at least ask people of similar handicaps to play together, but the two people had no idea at all. We felt we were holding the whole course up. These two hackers should not have been playing the Montgomerie Course at all, they must have lost about 20 balls each. No fun for us.

Stableford Score - 38 points

Handicap - 13

Stableford Score - 32 points

Handicap - 10

Long walk to have food but worth it when we arrived.

My Caddy Tip - "Practice putting."

Stableford Score - 35 points

Handicap - 35

I took a party of 44 to Celtic Manor in June 2012 and could not fault the accommodation, golf courses and food.

My Caddy Tip - "Book early and play quickly"

Stableford Score - 30 points

Handicap - 24

Superbly maintained golf courses. Greens good but tricky. Rooms excellent. Possibly would not return as the air conditioning in public rooms is most uncomfortable. Food cools far too quickly as a result.

Stableford Score - 30 points

Handicap - 15

What a place to play golf. Everything you need. The 2010 course is absolutely superb but very difficult from 11 to 14. Roman Road should not be taken lightly also and is particularly tough on the legs. Will definitely be going back. The staff working there, both in the hotel and on the golf course cannot help enough. Fantastic.

My Caddy Tip - "Watch out for holes 11 to 14 on the 2010. Lots of water and tight fairways."

Stableford Score - 30 points

Handicap - 4

Excellent customer service by all staff at the Manor. Courses in good nick &very challenging, try to play in Summer months without the wind. A must visit place for all keen Golfers.

My Caddy Tip - "Allow for the wind."

Stableford Score - 30 points

Handicap - 17

Course in good condition. Confusing price structure- I received a special offer golf price via email but no one knew about it and it took ages to resolve.

Stableford Score - 30 points

Handicap - 14

I went to Celtic Manor with some friends. While there we played only 9 holes of golf but enjoyed it. The deal I was offered included bed, breakfast and evening meal. The food was excellent. The room was large and in the Manor. The whole place was very busy even though it was mid week and not in school holidays. Staff were always very helpful and friendly.

Handicap - 36 or more

Overall a fantastic resort. Service in all areas was exceptional. Have already booked for next year.

My Caddy Tip - "Use a buggy for the Montgomerie."

Stableford Score - 30 points

Handicap - 20

The Manor house was terrific. Particularly liked the Cellar Bar and happy hour. The breakfast was superb and the staff couldn't do enough to ensure a comfortable stay. We played The Montgomerie Course and The Roman Road and the Monty was my favourite. Fantastic deal and all made easy by YGT.

Stableford Score - 38 points

Handicap - 12

The hotel was great. I prefer Roman Road to Montgomerie.

Stableford Score - 36 or more points

Handicap - 28 or less

18 hole was a great finish. Venue is one of the best I've been too, and despite it being a three hour drive I've played here for the last three years, once a year.

My Caddy Tip - "Keep it on the fairway at all costs."

Stableford Score - 33 points

Handicap - 13

3 great courses and each one was a tough test of golf for different reasons. The hotel (manor house) rooms were everything you'd expect of a 4* hotel.

My Caddy Tip - "Due to the amount of bunkers on the 2010 course being in the landing area of shots off the tee I would suggest clubbing down where you feel it calls for it. Then you are in a much better position to play your 2nd shots over these bunkers."

Stableford Score - 31 points

Handicap - 14

I like all of the holes.

Handicap - 14

Probably be back but playing 2 courses in 2 days in mid summer was tough going for me so I need to plan better next time.

Stableford Score - 32 points

Handicap - 22

The 14th was my favourite hole.

My Caddy Tip - "Enjoy the experience."

Stableford Score - 28 or less points

Handicap - 6

The main hotel was great, although the Manor was a bit tired with a few loud mouthed people in the bar there. The 2010 course was brilliant despite the excessive rain which filled the bunkers with water. We did swear that we'd go back and play it in better weather (if possible).

My Caddy Tip - "Buy a course guide."

Stableford Score - 30 points

Handicap - 22

Nice courses, bit of a hassle only driving on pathways with buggies. It slows games down.

My Caddy Tip - "Check distances."

Stableford Score - 36 points

Handicap - 8

I enjoyed the whole experience. The golf, our meal at the hotel and the accommodation all made the trip an enjoyable birthday treat.

Handicap - 27

Roman road and Montgomerie courses both have some great holes and some great views. I would recommend a buggy as the walk between some holes is quite long. Would like to have played the 2010 course but it was a bit pricey.

Stableford Score - 31 points

Handicap - 16

Celtic Manor is a great venue with top courses for a two/three day trip with everything on site for your group. 2010 course is tough but fair- high and low handicappers can all play it. Your ability determines how many balls you lose. I would go back.

My Caddy Tip - "Be aggressive."

Stableford Score - 30 points

Handicap - 5

All holes are good but take plenty of club on par three's. Hotel was first class and well presented.

My Caddy Tip - "Make sure you have a practice round and take notes."

Stableford Score - 38 points

Handicap - 5

Montgomerie was tougher than 2010. Enjoyed the dinner out facility with the courtesy coach ride. Hotel bedrooms were excellent. Less impressed with The Vale and would look for alternatives.

My Caddy Tip - "Hit the fairways."

Stableford Score - 28 or less points

Handicap - 20

Stableford Score - 30 points

Handicap - 20

The 14th hole on the Twenty Ten was fantastic. Hotel is excellent.

Stableford Score - 37 points

Handicap - 12

One of the best courses in the UK. The hotel and restaurants are fabulous as well.

My Caddy Tip - "Take plenty of balls."

Stableford Score - 28 or less points

Handicap - 23

Courses were in great condition despite the poor weather. The hotel was first class and served an excellent breakfast.

Stableford Score - 30 points

Handicap - 12

Stableford Score - 35 points

Handicap - 13

The 2010 is a must play for any golfer whatever their handicap.

My Caddy Tip - "Watch out for the speed of the greens and attack them with your short irons."

Stableford Score - 34 points

Handicap - 17

Hotel and staff were exceptional, food and service outstanding. We played on all three courses, the marquee course being 2010. However, all three are fantastic courses and I personally found the Roman Road to be the most challenging. The Montgomerie and Roman Road start from the main club house, views on the Montgomerie are fantastic though the course involves a lot of very steep hills. The Roman Road is a lovely course and the holes offer much variety but everyone wants the 2010, which surprisingly for the shorter hitting and higher handicaps proved very forgiving.

My Caddy Tip - "Go for it, don't hold back and have fun."

Stableford Score - 34 points

Handicap - 17

My Caddy Tip - "Use a buggy."

Handicap - 15

Beautiful course and layout, enjoyed the challenge.

Stableford Score - 32 points

Handicap - 16

Stay on the fairways on the Roman Road course. The Montgomerie has some great holes and views especially on the 3rd. A buggy is a must to make the most of your day. Excellent stewarding as they kept us aware of an imminent storm and made sure we got round ahead of it. Overall, a great day of golf.

My Caddy Tip - "Be prepared to use every club in your bag."

Stableford Score - 32 points

Handicap - 18

Need a buggy on the Montgomery course.

Stableford Score - 32 points

Handicap - 16

Great facility for all standards of golf. Hotel standards achieve customer delight. Although the food and beverages might appear expensive the overall package is good value for money and we will be returning asap.

My Caddy Tip - "Play within yourself."

Stableford Score - 28 or less points

Handicap - 21

The hotel was great. The staff were very friendly & helpful, walking down the eighteenth. Don't get buggy's as they are not allowed on the course and you have to stick to path so there is a lot of walking.

My Caddy Tip - "Just enjoy the moment."

Stableford Score - 28 or less points

Handicap - 14

15th, 16th, 17th and 18th all brilliant holes. Where possible take your time and think your way round. Hotel was very good.

Stableford Score - 32 points

Handicap - 18

Expensive drinks and food in hotel. Clubhouse and Pro Shop great location. Playing 2010 course should be on any golfers bucket list.

Stableford Score - 37 points

Handicap - 9

All of the holes were very good on the Celtic Manor 2010 course. I would recommend golfers to play this course at least once, and after once you would want to play it again. The hotel was superb and the room I had was for just myself and it was fantastic. Spa and pool was beautiful. The only one downside to it was they take £50 on your credit card card for incidentals. They charged me more money for my evening meal than I should have paid because they said I should have paid for the evening meal on line, even though I had confirmation that I would be charged less which was on my invoice from yourgolf travel.

My Caddy Tip - "17th is a fantastic par 3, a 3 wood is definitely is recommended."

Stableford Score - 30 points

Handicap - 12

I got a hole in one on a par 3 and won opportunity to play again on Montgomery/Roman Road. Good value for money, excellent helpful staff and a trio of fantastic well-cared-for courses. A joy to visit and experience where a Ryder Cup was played.

My Caddy Tip - "Use a distance measuring device"

Stableford Score - 28 or less points

Handicap - 20

Courses are very nice, would recommend buggy for the Montgomery. Resort hotel, facilities and restaurant were excellent.

Handicap - 18

Great courses, looking forward to playing the 2010.

Stableford Score - 35 points

Handicap - 14

Excellent golf challenge.

Stableford Score - 34 points

Handicap - 18

Can't really remember very much because it was 5 years ago. Sorry.

Handicap - 16

Hotel and organisation impersonal and unfriendly

My Caddy Tip - "Hotel and organisation impersonal and unfriendly"

Handicap - 8

Would love to go back on a sunny day. Lovely course and friendly staff at the venue. Would highly recommend the associated restaurant on the Usk, amazing. Pool was disappointing, as no where near as big as the images portrayed.

Handicap - 11

Top hotel, been there many times. Little peeved to have to pay for parking in a hotel now as a resident. The food was exceptional and I found both club houses relaxing, well stocked and with genuine staff to help your every need.

My Caddy Tip - "Don't go off the fairway on 2010, it's punishing."

Stableford Score - 34 points

Handicap - 10

The hotel was very busy and the service was poor. The food was also disappointing.

Handicap - 12

Enjoyed playing all 3 courses with my son and this was a great experience that we shared together. The 2010 course was a fantastic experience but we also very much enjoyed the Montgomery and Roman Road course. The greens are true and a lot faster than we are used to. The driving range is also great as is the accommodation. All the staff we interacted with were friendly and helpful which we appreciated. This was our second visit & I suspect it will not be our last.

My Caddy Tip - "Take a buggy to enjoy the views."

Stableford Score - 34 points

Handicap - 8

Favourite holes were the 3rd on the monty and the 8th on 2010.

Stableford Score - 30 points

Handicap - 10

The 2010 experience was fantastic, from the moment you arrive to the time you leave the club house. I found the course to be a real challenge, a little too long for my game.

My Caddy Tip - "Enjoy yourself "

Stableford Score - 32 points

Handicap - 8

Great facilities but the strength was the friendliness of the staff.

Stableford Score - 36 points

Handicap - 27

Every hole on the 3 courses is a good hole. We stayed in one of the lodges. Definitely recommended.

My Caddy Tip - "Take 1 more club than you think."

Stableford Score - 31 points

Handicap - 12

Hotel & facilities were excellent.

My Caddy Tip - "Enjoy it."

Stableford Score - 30 points

Handicap - 6

The hotel was very comfortable and plenty of restaurants serving good food at them all. It's better to play the same course twice, as one needs to get the correct line from the tee. It's easy to take the line that appears right, but then find you're blocked out to the green. Buggies must keep the paths, so if your ball is on the other side of the fairway, take two or more clubs when you walk to it. The last 4 holes are particularly tough and if you can manage them in 2 over par, you'll have a good score.

My Caddy Tip - "Some of the short holes need the extra club."

Stableford Score - 34 points

Handicap - 9

This was a great golf break with a comfortable hotel. The staff at the hotel were friendly. I loved the golf at the 2010 course, you were made to feel like a superstar by the attention given on arrival. The course is tricky but possible to play if you keep your thinking cap on. It is a course which allows you to have fun but you need to navigate your way round it. I loved the water holes and the uphill and downhill ones. The 15th is a special favourite for me. The 18th is a cracking finishing hole where you have to hold your breath as you attempt to go over the water to the green.

My Caddy Tip - "Think before you play."

Handicap - 14

The 1st hole on the 2010 course was my favourite hole because it was the start of a brilliant 2 days. Don't come with any preconceived ideas, and you will be pleasantly surprised. I could not fault anything about the hotel. We were well looked after throughout our stay and the food was smashing as was the service. I would recommend this venue to any golfer.

My Caddy Tip - "Club selection is vital."

Stableford Score - 28 or less points

Handicap - 26

Great course, great hotel, great golfing break. Would recommend to anyone.

Handicap - 20

The hotel was excellent and there was a great atmosphere at the piano bar. The rooms in the lodge were first rate. The golf courses were a fair test of golf and the starter was extremely helpful. The clubhouse was welcoming and the food was very good. The practice facilities were good and the practice green is a good example of the greens.

My Caddy Tip - "Ensure you spend enough time on the practice green so you get the pace right before you begin play."

Stableford Score - 34 points

Handicap - 4

Nice touches on 2010- balls on range, personalised market and clubs cleaned.

Stableford Score - 30 points

Handicap - 21

We found the resort hotel and its services excellent. The golf courses are fabulous and would suit all abilities. A buggy is a good option for all 3 courses but I'm lazy and like beer. The food is also top notch.

My Caddy Tip - "Enjoy the view and the company. Life is too short to be worrying about bad golf."

Stableford Score - 34 points

Handicap - 11

Played Roman Road and Montgomerie. Good tests of golf and in good condition. Accommodation was good too. Dinner was ok, but pricey.

My Caddy Tip - "Very fast greens."

Stableford Score - 30 points

Handicap - 19

2010 course was excellent- not too tight off the tee but you had to be very accurate playing into the greens. Course was in excellent condition. Next time I would walk the course as the buggy paths are too far away from the course. Hotel was very nice and had excellent service.

My Caddy Tip - "Give up some yardage from the tee to ensure you hit the fairway."

Stableford Score - 33 points

Handicap - 5

All courses were completely waterlogged. There was standing water everywhere yet we were still sent out to play. We were given a voucher on the 2nd day but it didn't cover cost of green fees on returning, Restaurant was nice but pricey. Hotel was ok, but nothing to get excited about.

Handicap - 11

I would eat in the grill at night. Did not like the buffet.

Stableford Score - 36 points

Handicap - 15

9th hole is long but rewarding. Great for long hitters.

My Caddy Tip - "Good course management at all times."

Stableford Score - 28 or less points

Handicap - 16

My only issue with the 2010 course was the speed of play. It took over 5 and half hours to play. My mate had to leave on the 16th as he has to go to work.

Stableford Score - 36 points

Handicap - 5

Hotel was fabulous and the course's were great. Tough for me only playing off a 36 handicap. Would go back again.

Handicap - 36 or more

The 2010 course was fantastic, with a number of great holes. Both Montgomerie and Roman Road are also both good courses with some memorable holes.

Stableford Score - 32 points

Handicap - 9

All brilliant holes and you need your thinking cap on.

My Caddy Tip - "Extra club for the wind."

Stableford Score - 28 or less points

Handicap - 8

Very tough course for the higher handicapper.

Stableford Score - 30 points

Handicap - 13

5* all round.

Stableford Score - 33 points

Handicap - 17

The accommodation was extremely poor- dirty worn and low grade. The reception staff showed no interest. The 2010 course was so wet, it was nearly unplayable. The buggy was useless as the buggy path was so far from the playing area. Rain on the second day so the course was closed. Would not think of recommending Celtic Manor to anybody.

Stableford Score - 35 points

Handicap - 13

Favourite hole is the 3rd on the Montgomerie. Stunning views over Usk valley, 600+ yards down hill.

My Caddy Tip - "Be prepared for a long walk to the 1st on the Montgomerie."

Stableford Score - 37 points

Handicap - 12

Montgomerie: very hilly, played with two members who guided us round, otherwise we would have struggled to place our shots in the right areas. A very slow round, 5 hours. 

 Roman Road: more difficult, greens very tricky. 

 Both courses were very busy, my wife and I had to play as a 4 ball - not ideal, but all players were in 4 balls. Hotel and restaurant were both excellent.

Stableford Score - 30 points

Handicap - 14

In contrast to other golf resorts that we visited on the same golf tour, every member of staff that we encountered during our stay was friendly, helpful and wanted us to enjoy every aspect of our time at Celtic Manor. We would definitely recommend playing all three courses if you can spare the time, and are prepared to pay the extra for TwentyTen.

Handicap - 17

Courses were good, although Roman Road is close to the road and I found this to be not so enjoyable as the Montgomerie course. Unfortunately the meal and service at the 2010 restaurant was not good, but the manager did speak to us personally and offered us a glass of champagne as an apology.

Handicap - 32

The hotel was brilliant.

My Caddy Tip - "Make use of the practice putting area."

Stableford Score - 35 points

Handicap - 16

The offer we had was incredible value. The staff were so lovely everywhere- the hotel reception, the bar, the breakfast waiters and waitresses and the golf staff. Well done to everyone and thank you. Both courses were immaculate. They were a great test of golf to any handicapper.

My Caddy Tip - "Get a buggy."

Stableford Score - 28 or less points

Handicap - 12

I like the 3 courses. My tip is to enjoy yourself, don't beat yourself up if you make a mistake. The hotel is 1st class. Great food, spa and a farewell breakfast as good as you'll get.

Stableford Score - 30 points

Handicap - 18

All 3 courses were great! Staff on the courses and club houses were very informative and very helpful. The hotel we stayed in (The Manor) was disappointing and we had issues with some of the staff taking money off my card without my authorisation.

Handicap - 15

Buggy expensive, but essential. Food in the self service restaurant was very ordinary.

Stableford Score - 28 or less points

Handicap - 24

Hotel great, organisation great. The 2010 course is difficult for high handicappers. Well worth the trip. Great value.

My Caddy Tip - "Relax"

Stableford Score - 33 points

Handicap - 14

The hotel was fantastic.

Stableford Score - 28 or less points

Handicap - 10

Played 2010 and Roman Road. 2010 is cruel- some shots appear great but the shaved banks and run-off areas can give a harsh outcome. Thoroughly enjoyed it and want to play it again. It does take time though and having to stick to buggy paths is a pain. I would probably walk next time. Roman Road was quirky and would also like to play again.

My Caddy Tip - Be conservative first time out."

Stableford Score - 28 or less points

Handicap - 18

All 3 courses will test any player.

My Caddy Tip - "Fairway play and putting on greens are key to these courses."

Stableford Score - 28 or less points

Handicap - 15

Fantastic venue with the atmosphere to match. To play where the big boys have been really shows how good they are. Wonderful layout and views. Most memorable.

My Caddy Tip - "The middle of the fairway is essential"

Stableford Score - 30 points

Handicap - 8

Twenty Ten course was fine, but the others not so good.

Stableford Score - 37 points

Handicap - 8

We played Roman Road and Montgomerie and there were some nice holes and a couple of quirky/blind holes. Hotel was nice, bar food was expensive, but nice pubs locally.

Stableford Score - 34 points

Handicap - 12

Hotel was great, and it is much cheaper to stay with your golf travel booking than booking direct.

Handicap - 26

Bought this as a gift for my mother for mothers day. Me and her played the golf and then my father stayed the night with my mother. Course was great and my parents said the hotel was 1st class. Definitely recommend the Celtic manor.

Stableford Score - 32 points

Handicap - 4

From the moment we arrived, the service provided by the staff in all areas was exceptional. The organisation was first class and the golf courses in pristine condition. My wife, who plays off 30, and myself both found all 3 courses an interesting challenge and particularly enjoyed the personal experience and excitement of the 2010. Room in the hotel was smashing, some fine bars and the course club rooms and the restaurants had a fine choice of quality food. The choice of food at breakfast was second to none, and really set you up for the day. We had a really great time, thank you.

My Caddy Tip - "Warm up on the 2010 driving range before you go to the first."

Stableford Score - 34 points

Handicap - 10

Great course. Very challenging but good fun. Unfortunately the hotel room was very warm overnight and I was unable to turn it down, which made for two sleepless sticky nights.

Handicap - 20

We've played both the Montgomerie and the Roman courses. Personally I prefer the Montgomerie because there are some very scenic holes, a handful with spectacular views. However I'd advise anyone playing the Montgomerie, at least to take a trolley and better still to take a buggy. Some of the green to tee walks are very hilly. Overall Celtic Manor is a wonderful golf venue and the best testament to this is that my golf group, who usually never return to the same courses for our annual trip, have now been back to Celtic Manor for three successive years, and planning a fourth in 2016.

Stableford Score - 34 points

Handicap - 21

The 2010 course at Celtic Manor is a 'must do' experience for keen golfers. Expect it to be tough though! We found the main hotel to be very busy and were pleased to have reserved a room in the annexe which was much more peaceful.

Stableford Score - 28 or less points

Handicap - 21

20 of us played 2010 & we all thought it was brilliant. All played Monty & as expected it was not as good as 2010, but still very good. Hotel and staff were excellent. Would look forward to returning.

Stableford Score - 30 points

Handicap - 14

The Monty 3rd hole was brilliant. Hotel was top class. Tip for playing- just enjoy it.

My Caddy Tip - "Go when it's dry."

Stableford Score - 38 points

Handicap - 15

On day one 20 Ten treated us like visiting professionals. Good experience playing the Ryder Cup course but not easy and a buggy helped. Hotel and restaurants super. Try dinner at the Rafters. Both Manor and Resort comfortable hotels. Montgomerie and Roman Road good test of golf. Staff across the resort friendly and helpful.

My Caddy Tip - "Take enough golf balls and enjoy the experience. "

Handicap - 14

17th hole was a great par 3. Make sure you carry plenty of spare balls. The hotel was 5 star.

My Caddy Tip - "Stay on the fairway as the rough is penalising."

Stableford Score - 28 or less points

Handicap - 18

People with buggies take twice as long from buggy to ball and then don't have the right club when they get there. Extremely slow and when we played the courses they were not up to standard. I think there is too much hype surrounding the courses.

My Caddy Tip - "Take wellingtons."

Stableford Score - 34 points

Handicap - 3

Plays on its name and is very busy. Suffers from fog due to its location. Although, the greens are good there are far better courses out there.

My Caddy Tip - "Go at the pins."

Stableford Score - 37 points

Handicap - 12

Really nice complex, hotel was nice with plenty to do. Rooms were nice and spacious. Courses were wet when we played them, still in good nick though. Would like to go back soon when weather is better.

My Caddy Tip - "Plot your way round"

Stableford Score - 30 points

Handicap - 9

I have been to Celtic Manor three times in small groups and think it is the best value for money resort. The staff go above the expected standard of service, the rooms are more than comfortable and the hotel is very restful. All 3 courses are challenging to the average golfer but I would not recommend a buggy. More trouble than worth as you have to stick to the paths and end up walking further. The hills on the Monty are very challenging for the not so fit. Going back next week.

My Caddy Tip - "Take your wet weather gear."

Stableford Score - 28 or less points

Handicap - 20

Hotel great. Loved the Montgomerie course, although Roman road was a bit long and boring

Stableford Score - 33 points

Handicap - 11

The Ryder cup and Roman Road courses where excellent and tough. We should have pre booked our restaurants. Our only choice was the buffet, and that wasn't that great, but that was our own fault. Drinks at the hotel are typical of any venue miles away from another bar, so we budgeted for this.

My Caddy Tip - "Go for it"

Stableford Score - 32 points

Handicap - 10

Hotel and staff are amazing.

My Caddy Tip - "Practice putting greens are lightning quick."

Stableford Score - 33 points

Handicap - 13

All good.

Stableford Score - 32 points

Handicap - 13

Par 5 on the Montgomerie overlooking the 2010 course was amazing. Great views.

Stableford Score - 30 points

Handicap - 16

Found the course fair, with some very hard holes and some easy ones. A fantastic venue for a golf break and the hotel is very good.

My Caddy Tip - "Make sure you have a practice round."

Stableford Score - 32 points

Handicap - 4

Just play the course and don't try and beat it. Also, when it says it's 150 yards to the green its to the front of the green, not the middle.

My Caddy Tip - "Just enjoy it "

Stableford Score - 32 points

Handicap - 12

Stableford Score - 28 or less points

Handicap - 20

The hotel is stunning and both the Montgomerie and Roman road courses are tough but fair. You might even get lucky with the weather. The Monty is my favourite with its dramatic elevation changes and it's always in tip top condition. The Roman Road has undergone some changes from when I first played there, but it hasn't done the course any harm. Everyone is friendly and helpful and I look forward to returning soon.

My Caddy Tip - "Buy a course planner for your fist round. It will pay for itself."

Stableford Score - 32 points

Handicap - 7

Roman Road was in nice condition. The Montgomerie was spoiled by traffic. It took four hours for nine holes so we walked off, back to the warmth of the jacuzzi. Buggies extortionate and a necessity for both courses. Hotel accommodation was great. Room was great, the spa was awesome, and the staff couldn't do enough for you. Evening meal at the hotel was a let down. Poor selection and quality, won't stay for the buffet again. I can only assume the a la carte menu was much better. All in all a pleasant stay but won't play the Montgomerie again.

My Caddy Tip - "Get a buggy."

Stableford Score - 36 points

Handicap - 2

Celtic Manor provides all you could want in a golfing venue. Stay at the resort if you can, rather than the older, but still very nice Manor. The Manor was once a maternity home and is steeped in local history so you'll still love the experience. The 2010 experience is fantastic; the course may not be the most beautiful you'll ever play, but remember who did what and where and you'll have a thrilling time. The other courses are very good; have a buggy for Roman Road. Many GPS devices are wrong on all 3 courses. Take a laser if you have one and buy a course guide.

My Caddy Tip - "Be long rather than short when hitting into 18 on the 2010."

Stableford Score - 33 points

Handicap - 12

Although the Welsh weather was not kind to us, we still had a great time at the resort. It offers great value when compared to other venues around the UK that have hosted big events. For anyone who went to the 2010 Ryder Cup, playing the 2010 course is a must. It's amazing how many shots you remember seeing and how few you are able to recreate (other than the Mahan duff on 17!). Beware: The 18th hole is a very tough test on a wet day when playing into the wind.

My Caddy Tip - "Play within yourself. Play safe to hit fairways & avoid the long rough at all costs."

Stableford Score - 28 or less points

Handicap - 18

None of the courses lived up to my expectations.

Stableford Score - 32 points

Handicap - 13

Super courses. However, did not play main course as we played the week before the rainy Rider cup. Hotel was fab but we had upgraded to the main hotel and not the golf hotel. Really super facilities, food and golf for 2!

My Caddy Tip - "Don't carry on the Montgomery unless you are a Billy Goat. "

Stableford Score - 36 points

Handicap - 18

You need a buggy for the course and green to tee is a very long walk.

Handicap - 18

2010 was a great course.

My Caddy Tip - "Don't go left"

Stableford Score - 28 or less points

Handicap - 12

The 2010 course was tough.

My Caddy Tip - "Play safe."

Stableford Score - 30 points

Handicap - 16

Great facilities, and both the Mongomerie and 2010 are great courses.

My Caddy Tip - "Keep on the fairway."

Stableford Score - 32 points

Handicap - 8

Hotel was fine. Room was well appointed and very comfortable. Beer prices towards the upper end as you would expect but not up to London levels. Good breakfast with regular hot additions to the self-service buffet. Some significant walks available within the hotel itself! Strongly advise buggies as green to next tee, particularly on Montgomerie as it can be long and very steep! Great views and pretty good courses in good condition.

My Caddy Tip - "Look for another caddy."

Stableford Score - 30 points

Handicap - 14

First tee of Montgomerie was long and had a dog leg keep so if you go down the middle, you have to smash it. Hotel great, Manor House OK. I lost a golf club out of my bag after the staff put my bag out for the next morning before we teed off.

My Caddy Tip - "Just keep it straight, no need for trying to hit the skin off the ball, just play within yourself."

Stableford Score - 37 points

Handicap - 17

The Celtic Manor Resort was brilliant, they can't do enough for you and really make the effort to make your trip enjoyable. Great value for money and highly recommended.

My Caddy Tip - "Don't miss the fairways."

Stableford Score - 34 points

Handicap - 14

The 2010 course was a great experience. I found it great to walk rather than take a buggy. You have to think your way round the course as every hole has its own challenge whether it is lots of bunkers (2nd hole) or water, hills, slopes etc. Great halfway house and was very welcome at that point of the round. 18th was great as it was a challenge to land on the green and not roll back into the water or not over hit it and put it in to one of a number of bunkers. Clubhouse was great and had a great balcony to watch others attempting the 18th.

My Caddy Tip - "Think about what is in front of you and be realistic about the distances you can hit the ball."

Stableford Score - 34 points

Handicap - 14

On the 2010 course all the holes had there own problems. A good test of golf apart from hole 15.

Handicap - 10

Played the Montgomerie with a buggy, but didn't realise you had to stay on the buggy track all the time, which was a bit of pain.

Handicap - 21

Hotel was good, breakfast was marvelous. Practice facilities were superb. However, the courses were really busy, and the rounds were slow.

My Caddy Tip - "Placement off the tee is key."

Stableford Score - 34 points

Handicap - 10

The hotel was great. 2010 booking in. All round service is exceptional- 5 star. Must visit and will again.

My Caddy Tip - "Get a buggy."

Stableford Score - 30 points

Handicap - 15

Loved the course and loved the hotel. Would love to do it all again.

My Caddy Tip - "Don't go for the green in two at 18."

Stableford Score - 34 points

Handicap - 20

Great hotel with 3 fantastic golf courses on the doorstep.

My Caddy Tip - "Practice long putts before you go."

Stableford Score - 32 points

Handicap - 4

Pre-booking of meals is a must. Montgomerie was a big surprise. 2010 was a little disappointing. Roman was as expected.

My Caddy Tip - "Buggies are a good idea."

Stableford Score - 30 points

Handicap - 10

Roman Road was my favourite course.

My Caddy Tip - "Take an iron"

Stableford Score - 34 points

Handicap - 4

All golf holes where great. Hotel was very nice.

My Caddy Tip - "Enjoy your round."

Stableford Score - 36 points

Handicap - 12

All three courses are a challenge but 2010 is something special. All the staff go out of their way to make it a great day. Nice touches with your name on the lockers and a bag tag.

My Caddy Tip - "Think your way round and make the most of your handicap."

Stableford Score - 30 points

Handicap - 18